Tuesday, October 27, 2026

Hunger Games ‘Shipping Notes

 

 The fourth in a series of Hunger Games posts by Mary Baldwin College professor Louise Freeman:

Random musings

Prim points out after the first Reaping that if Katniss wins, they’ll be “as rich an Haymitch.”  But the state of his house makes it appears as though Haymitch still lives in poverty, despite a quarter century of Victor’s income, with no dependents to support.  It takes him 25 years to hire a maid?  What’s he supposed to be spending all his money on?  And don’t tell me liquor; with the income of a Games champion he could set Ripper up for life if she agreed to run a personal still for him in his cellar. My only thought is that he funnels his money to revolutionaries. Or perhaps he forged alliances with the other Mentors by providing for the families of the Tributes they lost, as Peeta tried to do for Rue and Thresh’s loved ones.

Peeta Mellark as a Neville-Echo

 

More Hunger Games thoughts from Mary Baldwin College Professor Louise Freeman:

The Peeta-Neville connection

My first impression of Peeta is that he reminded me of Neville Longbottom and my second reading, if anything, reinforced that image. While the “stocky” 16-year old Peeta may be capable of slinging 100 lb bags of flour, I imagine the 11-year-old of Katniss’s memories as a pudgy and not noticeably talented child, similar to Neville in the early years of Harry Potter.  He is bullied by his mother much as Neville was browbeaten by his Gran; though, somehow I don’t see a proud Mama Mellark showing up to assist at the final battle of Mockingjay, as Augusta did in Deathly Hallows.  Like Neville, Peeta showed a spark of heroic potential as a child; he summoned enough courage to defy his mother and toss a couple of bread loaves to a starving classmate (and got beaten for his efforts) just as Neville’s courage in standing up to the Trio got him petrificused by Hermione. But let’s face it, at this stage, a baker’s child with a talent for cake decorating seems to have as much champion potential as a chronic toad-loser with a talent for herbology. But both 11-year-olds tipped a delicate balance in favor of the good guys at a crucial moment; Peeta’s burnt bread gave Katniss the strength to provide for her family, while Neville’s 10 points secured the House cup for Gryffindor. Both are vessels of heroic potential in unlikely packages.

Hunger Games Mark Evanses & Names


More from Prof. Louise Freeman at Mary Baldwin College on neglected details in Suzanne Collins’ The Hunger Games!

“Mark Evanses”

(What is a ‘Mark Evans’? People we’ve heard mentioned in the story but not been told about who could turn out to be important later, or could just as likely be nobodies. Read here for the Harry Potter reference.)

  1. Peeta’s brothers. We know Prim from the get-go. We at least meet and learn something about Gale’s siblings: their ages, genders, the fact that little Rory registers for tesserae and was starting to learn hunting. All we know is that Peeta has two older brothers, one likely too old to be in the Games, the other eligible but who Katniss flatly states “won’t” volunteer to take his kid brother’s place.  Either Brother #2 knows of the Pearl Plot and realizes Peeta’s the best to court the Mockingjay, or he takes after his mom.
  2. The third District 12 Hunger Games Victor. We know nothing about this person, other than he/she is deceased and presumably won before Haymitch did.  It seems strange to mention this person and never follow up.  Will this person turn out to be a grandparent of one of our protagonists or a relative of someone else we know? Was he/she a contemporary of Mags who inspired revolution by carefully mentoring Haymitch?
  3. The fourth District 12 tribute from the 2nd Quarter Quell. The first called was a anonymous Seam girl, the second Maysilee Donner. Katniss is too taken aback by the revelations about Maysilee and the sight of her mother as a child to notice when the first male tribute is called and only appears to pick up watching again when Haymitch shows up on the tape. Again, it seems odd for Collins not to describe Tribute #3, not even in the nondescript way of QQ Girl #1. Could this man have an unrevealed connection to one of the current players?  Or could Peeta, yet again, be hiding something from Katniss and launch into the details of Maysilee, “Pearl” and Mrs. Everdeen as a means of distraction?

Mockingjay Discussion 17: Books vs. Broadcast

 

From Hogwarts Professor Louise Freeman in Virginia, thoughts on ‘Mockingjay,’ media, books, and truth, not to mention a contrast with Harry Potter:

“Beauty is truth and truth, beauty–that is all ye know on earth and all ye need to know.”  John Keats.

The Hunger Games trilogy gave us the harshest skewering of the media since Rita Skeeter, and with much less comic relief.  The first two books show the broadcast Games, “reality” TV twisted into a weapon of oppression and packaged as entertainment. Mockingjay shift gears into “informational” broadcasts twisted into weapons of war; they don’t even bother calling them “news broadcasts” but “propos,” a nickname for propaganda. In the end, there’s little difference between the two formats.

However, in Harry Potter, the target of the critique is the printed word:  the Daily “Profit”, the “whatever sells” writings of Skeeter and Lockhart; in Hunger Games, it’s all about television. There is little evidence that print media even exists; for all their electronic expertise, Panem society seems forgotten that the printing press or moveable type were ever invented. The only books we hear about are homemade, handwritten works.

Mockingjay Discussion 21: What the Votes Tell Us

 

From Hogwarts Professor Louise Freeman in Virginia:

The assembly of the Council of Victors to vote on whether or not to punish the Capitol with a final (yeah, right!) Hunger Games is a pivotal scene of Mockingjay.  The obvious question we are supposed to ask is “Why did Katniss vote yes?” Was she still so bitter over Prim’s death and convinced that the Capitol was responsible that she would go along with the act of vengeance?  Or did she instantly have an “Animal Farm” style realization that Coin was no different than Snow and give the Yes vote as her best chance to kill her?  I have my own idea, but I can see how there would be differing opinions.  It might be more beneficial to ask two other questions:  1) Why did Coin call for the vote?  2) Why did the other Victors vote the way they did?

“Heavensbee? Heavensbee?” On the loss of Philip Seymour Hoffman

 

Sad news this morning that Philip Seymour Hoffman, the Hunger Games‘ movie franchise’s Plutarch Heavensbee was found dead this morning at the age of 46,  of an apparent drug overdose. Our heartfelt condolences to his family and loved ones.

Mr. Hoffman had received many accolades for his film roles and his portrayal of the Gamesmaker-turned-revolutionary was one of the many welcome additions to Catching Fire. He had been set to reprise the role in Mockingjay.

Top 10 Reasons You Will like the Catching Fire Movie better than the Original.

 

I think we’ve hit that ever-so-rare Wrath of Khan phenomenon, where the sequel to a movie far surpasses the original. And, though I know our Headmaster had his issues with it, the Hunger Games franchise certainly did not start from as low a point as Star Trek: The Motion Picture.

I hit the 8:30 showing with my seventeen-year-old daughter and two of her friends last night, breaking my usual rule of no post 10-PM activities on a school night.  And, I am glad I did because I think this will go down as a memory my daughter and I will treasure. There was a unanimous consensus that this movie was a better and more faithful adaptation of the book.  Personally, I have always thought Catching Fire, though quite good, was the weakest of the trilogy.  It would not surprise me if the movie turns out to be the strongest.

Saturday, October 3, 2026

The WSJ Op-Ed on Young Adult Fiction that made Rita Skeeter look Impressive

 


Last June, I had the privilege of being invited to attend and present at the first, and I hope annual, Summit on the Research and Teaching of Young Adult Literature in Las Vegas. I attended many fine
talks from authors, educators and researchers, met Dr. Kia Richmond, who has written a book on mental illness in young adult literature and gave a talk on PTSD in young adult literature, including Harry Potter and The Hunger Games. Perhaps most exciting aspect was the opportunity to speak about PTSD in Laurie Halse Anderson‘s Speak and The Impossible Knife of Memory, with the author herself in the audience. Luckily for me, Ms. Anderson was both gracious with her comments and generous with her support for my work, in addition to being an all-around very cool person.

They say any publicity is good publicity, so I suppose the Summit organizer, Dr. Steven Bickmore, should have been glad to see the event as the subject of a Wall Street Journal editorial. However, the WSJ author, Steven Salerno, chose to devote 723 of 782 words of his column to criticizing the Summit, three of its guest authors and their books, for the crime of depicting a world  “spinning off its axis” with overly dark tales of dystopia, mental illness, racism, and other signs of depravity. Like the “Harry Haters” who decried the Potter books as a gateway to the occult without even a cursory reading that would have detected traditional Christian symbolism and pro-social themes, Salerno apparently formulated his opinion without attending the summit or interviewing the attendees he quoted. Instead, he appears to have pulled all of his information from other published summaries. Rita Skeeter, for all her faults, at least made a pretense of speaking to a few Harry’s, Bathilda’s and Pansy’s before misrepresenting their words and  twisting them to fit the scandalous story she had already decided to tell.

Ascendant (aka Allegiant Part Two) Movie cancelled; may be TV movie instead.

 

Divergent-Allegiant-Movie-PosterThis news broke a couple of days ago on Variety, and has not been confirmed by Lionsgate; but it also has not been denied, so I guess it is true. Allegiant-the-movie (or rather, Allegiant-the-movie-somewhat-loosely-inspired-by Veronica Roth’s-Allegiant-the-novel) failed to scale the high wall of acceptable reviews and–more importantly, no doubt–box office proceeds.  Lionsgate has decided not to proceed with Ascendant-the-movie, but rather will tie up the franchise with a TV movie, that will hopefully launch a new TV series with different characters set in Roth’s dystopia.

Insurgent Movie Strays from Book, but Strangely Satisfies.

 March 21, 2015 by 11 Comments

I went into the Insurgent film without a lot of high hopes.  I came out quite surprised at how much I liked it, and even more surprised by the reason.  Because it was the same reason that usually has me hating movie adaptations of favorite books.  Because the filmmakers deviated so much from the source material.  At the end of the day, this was an action movie loosely based on Roth’s Insurgent, not Insurgent:the Movie.  If you are expecting as faithful a book adaptation as the Harry Potter and Hunger Games franchises, or even the first Divergent movie, you will be disappointed.  The percentage of book-congruent material is closer to that of the Little House TV series. But remarkably, the film mostly worked for me.

Divergent Movie: First Impressions

 

It was a beautiful snowy night in beautiful downtown Staunton, Virginia, when, inspired by Elizabeth Baird Hardy’s outings with her Hunger Games readers, a colleague and I went with about 60 Mary Baldwin psychology students to see Divergent at  the historic Dixie theater.  Granted, it was March 25th, a few days after the movie’s big opening weekend, and, at that time of year, a beautiful spring evening would have been far more appropriate, but that wasn’t going to spoil our fun.

Judging from both the turnout for the film and the comments afterwards, this was a movie the students were eagerly anticipated and which lived up to their expectations.  Since my colleague is teaching personality psychology this term, we could not resist indoctrinating them on the Five Factor Hypothesis. But, with their finals coming up in only a couple of weeks, I figure the odds of the students remembering what O.C.E.A.N stands for are a bit more in their favor now.  At least two students have told me they were inspired to read the series now, which is always a desirable outcome.

Spoilers, ho!

Another writer notes the Divergent-Personality test link.

 


See? It’s not just me….

Laura Moss of Mother Nature Network has written a fascinating article linking the Factions of Divergent, the Houses of Hogwarts, the Breakfast Club and Buzzfeed quizzes to personality theory and people’s need to define themselves.   Please discuss! Does the quick-and-easy “sorting” of the protagonists into “the simplest terms, the most convenient definitions” explain the popularity of Tris (and Katniss and Harry), especially for adolescents who are seeking their own identity?  Is this why Facebook abounds with quizzes that claim to tell us which Broadway Musical or Starship Enterprise captain we really are, with a few clicks of the mouse?

What This Blog Is About.

What are the Farting Sofa Faculty Archives?

 Over a span of 10+ years, I published hundreds of blog posts on the Hogwarts Professor site. Most were essays on Harry Potter, the Hunger G...